Frankie Muniz and Witney Carson earned their first perfect score for their dramatic contemporary dance to Sting's "Every Breath You Take."
But Like any good Halloween-themed production, Dancing With the Stars' spooky Monday night episode ended in a surprise slashing.
After being delivered the results by the grim reaper, host Tom Bergeron announced that in an elimination "shocker," two contestants would be going home: Nikki Bella and Vanessa Lachey.
With the strange turn of events, there wasn't even time for the two to give a proper goodbye. Highlights of the night included a perfect score from also Jordan Fisher and Lindsay Arnold for their werewolf-themed paso doble. Bruno called it, "The biggest, baddest paso ever!"