WATCH: Frankie & Witney Earn First Perfect Score On DWTS Halloween Episode

Frankie Muniz and Witney Carson earned their first perfect score for their dramatic contemporary dance to Sting's "Every Breath You Take."

But Like any good Halloween-themed production, Dancing With the Stars' spooky Monday night episode ended in a surprise slashing. 

After being delivered the results by the grim reaper, host Tom Bergeron announced that in an elimination "shocker," two contestants would be going home: Nikki Bella and Vanessa Lachey. 

With the strange turn of events, there wasn't even time for the two to give a proper goodbye. Highlights of the night included a perfect score from also Jordan Fisher and Lindsay Arnold for their werewolf-themed paso doble. Bruno called it, "The biggest, baddest paso ever!"